Puerto Nuevo Mexican & Seafood Restaurant

4.7 (234 reviews )
$$
Mexican restaurant
Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
+(11)

About Puerto Nuevo Mexican & Seafood Restaurant

At Puerto Nuevo Mexican & Seafood Restaurant, the essence of Mexican cuisine meets coastal charm in Banner Elk, NC. Here, every dish tells a story, from the vibrant Texas Fajitas Nachos to the refreshing fish tacos, made with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. Guests are welcomed into a lively atmosphere complemented by an inviting salsa bar, featuring must-try options like mango and verde salsas. Customers rave about the fast, attentive service and the rich flavors that define each meal. Whether you’re dining with a group or looking for a cozy meal, Puerto Nuevo is a culinary gem that promises unforgettable dining experiences.

Reviews (234) 4.7

  • Ashley S.
    May 15,2025

    First time visiting. The service and food were amazing, and the atmosphere was very well lit and welcoming. He had the fish tacos, and I had the taco salad. Both were very fresh and really tasty. The server made sure we had everything we needed. The salsa bar had multiple choices. UPDATE-Second time and we wanted a light lunch. Chips, salsa bar(try the mango salsa, and the Verde salsa both are SO good). That is a Large Margarita in the photo. We also got the chicken wings, well I should say he did and he said they were really good.

  • Anna Blackman
    May 5,2025

    Everything about Puerto Nuevo was wonderful. The service, the atmosphere and especially the food. We were a party of 6 and everyones dish (and drink) was delicious. Highly recommend.

  • Gabe Young
    Apr 16,2025

    Pretty nice restaurant. The service was probably the fastest I’ve ever experienced our food was out in less than 10 minutes. It was also incredible. It was well seasoned and cooked almost perfectly. Really have no complaints at all about the place it was great!

  • Yeni U.
    Apr 9,2025

    Delicious mexican food with great service. The portions are good, and they have a variety of desserts and salsas.

  • David Cook
    Mar 18,2025

    Raw oysters were awesome. Very fresh. Tamalaes, chicken soup, & large Margaritas were A. Ramon was our server & did a superb job. Will b back

  • Greg Reed
    Feb 25,2025

    The salsa bar is the star of this restaurant! The food is excellent here and service is fast. Everyone was friendly and I recommend the food here when you're passing through.

  • Grace S
    Feb 15,2025

    The locals are right about this place. So happy to finally try this Mexican place out. Place was busy but service was super fast. Chips and dip were on the table even before we sat down. Beautiful and delicious margaritas though it was a bit hard to understand pricing as it was not on the menu. The chicken tortilla soup with rice was out of this world! Simply the best tortilla soup we ever had. We will come back just to have this soup! The mix beef and chicken fajitas was good but not the best we have had. Oh, not to forget the salsa bar which makes eating the chips even more fun. We tried several different ones and they are all so good! And servers who stacked multiple places on their arms are just so amazing. We will definitely be back!

  • Janine Carrington
    Jan 29,2025

    This place was fantastic! The service was impeccable, the food was delicious, and the drinks were so good and almost too pretty to drink! My husband and I had great conversation with our waitress and let her know we loved the food but hated that we’re not from around the area but from GA. She later came back with a little slip of paper letting us know there’s one close to where we live! That was so thoughtful of her. The manager was also so on top of things, which explains why the restaurant is doing so well. We would love to come back if we’re ever in the area again. Stop by, you will not be disappointed!

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Puerto Nuevo Mexican & Seafood Restaurant?

    Some popular dishes include the fish tacos, taco salad, seafood dinner platters, and the renowned chicken tortilla soup.

  • Do I need a reservation to dine at Puerto Nuevo?

    No, the restaurant welcomes both walk-ins and reservations, making it easy for you to enjoy a meal anytime.

  • What dining options are available at this restaurant?

    You can choose to dine in comfortably, enjoy outdoor seating, or grab takeout for a quick meal. Delivery is also available!

  • What is the atmosphere like at Puerto Nuevo?

    The atmosphere is cozy and trendy, perfect for families, groups, or solo dining. It’s especially nice during lunch or dinner hours.

  • Is there parking available at the restaurant?

    Yes, there is free parking available both in the lot and on the street for your convenience.

Nearby Mexican restaurants

Mexican restaurant
La Botana Mexican Restaurant Winston-Salem

1547 Hanes Mall Blvd, Winston-Salem, NC 27103

Mexican restaurant
El Ranchero Mexican Restaurant

2780 Durham Rd, Roxboro, NC 27573

Mexican restaurant
Calentano Mexican restaurant

614 W Harden St, Graham, NC 27253

Mexican restaurant
Santa Lucia Market

1100 River St, Wilkesboro, NC 28697

Mexican restaurant
La Carreta Mexican Restaurant

1033 Randolph St, Thomasville, NC 27360

Mexican restaurant
Casa Vallarta Mexican and Seafood Grill

3915 Battleground Ave, Greensboro, NC 27410

Mexican restaurant
Taqueria Los Juanes

373 Jonestown Rd Winston-Salem, NC 27104 United States

Mexican restaurant
Taco Mama - Dilworth

2452 Park Rd Ste C Charlotte, NC 28203 United States

Mexican restaurant
El Taco Shop

1049 Yadkinville Rd Mocksville, NC 27028 United States

Mexican restaurant
Los Amigos Mexican

1325 Memorial Dr E Ahoskie, NC 27910 United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page